Global Financial Crisis replay: hold or panic-sell?

The Lehman-era crash. The Nifty 50 lost 60% between January and October 2008: the replay where selling early really did win. In this replay a ₹1,00,000 portfolio that moves with the Nifty 50 splits in two on day three: one investor holds, the other sells everything at that day's close and stays in cash. Within this window, the panic-seller finished 145.6% ahead of holding.

Every step of the replay is a real daily closing level of the Nifty 50.

Window
Jan 8, 2008 to Oct 27, 2008
Index fall at its worst
59.9%
Recovery
496 trading days
Held portfolio at the end
₹40,144
Panic-sold on day 3
₹98,604

What happened, day by day

  1. Day 0. 8 Jan 2008. The Nifty 50 closes at a record 6,287.85 after a five-year bull run. Your ₹1,00,000 is invested across the Nifty 50.
  2. Day 3. Day 3. The Nifty is only 1.4% off its record, but American banks keep reporting losses on subprime loans. You sell everything at the close and keep ₹98,604 in cash.
  3. Day 10. 22 Jan. The market falls so fast at the open that trading is halted for an hour. In two sessions the Nifty has lost 14%. It is now 22% below your start.
  4. Day 48. 17 Mar. The US bank Bear Stearns has been rescued over the weekend. The Nifty closes 28% below your start, and the panic-seller looks like a genius.
  5. Day 170. 15 Sep. Lehman Brothers files for bankruptcy in New York. The Nifty falls 3.7% and is 35% below your start. The worst is still six weeks away.
  6. Day 198. 27 Oct 2008. The Nifty closes at 2,524.2, 59.9% below your start. Held: ₹40,144. Panic-sold: ₹98,604, almost two and a half times as much. Here, selling early won. The catch: the Nifty was back above its January 2008 level by 9 Nov 2010, and anyone still waiting in cash for the right moment missed that recovery.

The lesson

Crashes feel endless from the inside, and the urge to sell is strongest near the bottom. Replaying one lets you feel that pressure with virtual money and see how the decision played out. StockSaathi's coach uses the same idea in live trading: before a likely panic-sell it shows how often that stock's past falls recovered, how long that took and which never did, then lets you decide.

More crash replays

Create a free account → Beginner's guide